issue with the Pay to win of Avalon is that there's no cap for certain trinkets. This got to a point where someone roamed around with 14 fire flies, which basically meant the guy could regenerate back to full hp unless you somehow one shotted him from full or with an execution move. The Devs kind of got money hungry at one point, and began to really tilt the balance on the trinkets to the cash payer's favor heavily, and that drove the players out.
...Well that or the allegations that the head admin is a pedophile sexual predator who commonly grooms young boys on his mud. Not sure how true that is, but it did ick some people away from the mud when it was posted on r/ muds.