yes, correct. both braille me's editor and book reader have some showstopper issues for now. and for now you can get braille output, you must use your computer keyboard for input. see this google document i made.

https://drive.google.com/open?id=1gl5ZN … fX4vVip3n0

Thumbs up


I, too, am very happy for the review. I'm very close to buying an Orbit Reader for myself. I was always drawn more to that project than the others for some reason, and I feel that it wouldn't be a bad decision if I go for it. In a couple of months, I really think I'm going to get one, seeing as how I mainly wanted it for reading books anyway, so the lack of cursor routing buttons isn't a dealbreaker.

As for the number of cells debate, I agree that more is better for serious reading, but you learn to make do on a smaller display if you have to. I had an 18-cell Braille Note MPower, still do, actually, but it's broken, and that didn't put a cramp in my style too much for reading, despite the fact that I had been accustomed to a Braille Lite 40 for quite a few years before that. So, for these low cost displays, I can see why companies want to start smaller until they see how marketable these things are, and how much it will ultimately cost to make bigger displays available.

The glass is neither half empty nor half full. It's just holding half the amount it can potentially hold.

Thumbs up


speaking of the orbit reader 20. I ordered mine at the beginning of the month and really haven't got a clue if they even processed my order or not. The order is there and pending processing but ... come on..., seriously, that much time? or is there an announcement I just never saw?

Thumbs up


@Turtlepower17: I'm leaning towards BrailleMe, save the issues OP has mentioned. Especially with it's near-instant refresh rate. I don't want to make the same mistake I did with the SmartBeetle though and buy it too early when the blindness market hasn't caught up in terms of support for it yet. Also, I'm interested to see what happens later on. If this trend continues, we'll probably have something even better come down the pipeline soon enough.

Thumbs up


as of now though, the Orbit Reader20 has the best braille cells. The braille me dots are a bit weak. I was reading with it hooked to my computer today so NVDA could take care of wordWrap and everything like that. With braille me as it is now, some dots are higher than others, and for spaces and stuff dots stay slightly above the face plate making reading a bit difficult on braille me. I did write to the braille me developers about this though.

Thumbs up +1


would the orbit be able to coap with subtitles from netflix?

Or is the refresh rate too slow, I know you said it's like half a second, which isn't really a big deal if you're reading a book, but some of those Asian shows, with speech at least, need to be sped up, otherwise you miss things.

Thumbs up


maybe not if it takes a half second to refresh as stated by other posters. By the time one would appear, scant opportunity to read before the next comes.

The bipeds think this place belongs to them, how cute.

Thumbs up


@joshknnd1982: Thanks for the continued critique of the device. I'm really appreciating your personal experiences with it since you're pointing out issues that would likely be of annoyance to many people. This is really helpful!

@kool_turk: this is my concern with the display also and why I'm digging BrailleMe so far. Seems like most people who are using it are using it for reading and not real-time stuff.

Thumbs up

34 (edited by joshknnd1982 2018-06-23 20:43:20)

reading with braille me.
When reading with braille me, it feels like when there are unused dots either in letters or spaces, it feels like someone took a braille eraser on paper braille and did a bad erasing job. The orbit reader20 nor braille lite from the now dead blazie engineering nor braille note and other displays i have used, all of those others do  not exhibit this behavior where it feels like I am reading good braille with a large mixture of erased braille or rubbed-out-dots. I think this is why it is easier to read on the orbit20 and other older piezoelectric displays. Also I can tell on braille me some dots are significantly lower. On orbit20 sometimes a dot may be a millimeter or maybe half millimeter lower, but this does not affect reading. Probably because orbit20 does not give me the feeling of reading good braille with erased braille. many times on braille me I have to go back and say, wait a minute, is this a b? a letter l? is this e-d, or the "and", sign? when reading with braille me i second-guess myself due to the feeling of reading badly erased braille mixed with good braille with some dots higher some lower and some ever so slightly angled.

Thumbs up +2


I just had a conversation with the brailleme developers and thought I should report on it specially so, because I had been crying over the 40kb file limit lack of folder support and so on.
Not all of it has been taken care of,but should be pretty soon, according to the developers.
Here is what they said.

brailleme team wrote:

Its a pleasure to hear from you again following our interaction in January this year. We at Innovision had taken your feedback regarding file size limitation
and root folder sub directories into consideration. We are happy to share that the updated version of BrailleMe has resolved both of these issues. Please
find below a list of added functionality in BrailleMe version 2.
Hardware modifications:
- USB based Firmware upgrade feature added
- Increased memory for processing
- Faster SD card support (Helps in reading and writing large files)
- Improved carrying case based on user inputs 
- Improved device foots to avoid slipping on surfaces
- Decreased the size of the charger (now wall mounted)
- Added chip to support USB pen drives in the future
Software modifications:
- Read mode: Ability to open TXT files of unlimited size in grade 1 and grade 2
- Write mode: Increased file capacity to 100kB with grade 1 and grade 2 switching
- Save as braille: In certain languages where the back translation is not good, the user can save the file as a braille file. This will not create any
discrepancy in what the user reads and writes. These braille files can be edited and can be 100kB in size.
- iOS and Android support: Both OSes are now supported.
- Refined braille tables for English and regional Indian languages
- Revamped command table to adhere to legacy commands
The following features are currently under development and are expected to be released by end of July (currently being beta tested)
- Word wrap
- Cut-copy-paste
- context based quick Command guide
- Folder options
In case of any additional queries please let us know.

At anyone that has used both orbit reader and the brailleme, could you suggest me which one to choose? given an option.
I probably have the option to choose between a orbit reader, or a brailleme. the orbit reader is available in limited quantities though,so can run out any time soon, and the seller (an NGO) wont hold itself responsible for the warranty and I would have to deal directly with the manufacturers.
Where as the brailleme guys are located in my city itself, and so if they provide any warranty it should be easy to get to.
Ideas suggestions are welcome.

Of all sad words of tongue or pen, the saddest are these, ‘It might have been.
Follow me on twitter

Thumbs up


I would choose the orbit reader because the braille on the braille me when i got it feels like reading badly erased braille mixed with good braille.

Thumbs up


@cool_turk, I'd like to know how you could get subtitles to automatically come up in netflix in the first place, since I haven't figured that out yet. lol


Thumbs up


There's a couple of ways to do it, the easiest way is when you're playing something with subtitles.

Turn the rotor till you get to media descriptions, you'll see three options, speech, braille, speech and braille, and finally, off.

Funnily enough that rotor option also appears when you invoke Siri, no idea why, but it saves you trying to dig around for it in the settings.

Thumbs up