This topic is...ahem, still alive?
I'm reviving it only because others have before me, and I figure this is a well-established thread already. Why make another? Its last post was almost three years back, but jumps of a year or two have happened before. Either way, don't blame me. Maybe one some zombie or other got its teeth into it. Or maybe I'm a zombie.
Anyway, I just binge-watched the whole main series, and I have this to say.
For anyone still reading, definite
spoilers
follow
Still here? Okay, gonna let rip.
I mostly liked this series. Audio production was good (not great). I noticed a lot of stock sounds, and a lot of inconsistencies (especially in the earlier seasons). A couple of the voice actors got on my very last nerve (Scratch when she yells, Lizzy, Angel and Michael with the way they sometimes phrase things). Some of the narrated bits are just straight-up clunky. Oh and also? The past tense of "drag" is "dragged", not "drug". They made this mistake three or four times.
As far as characters? My favourites were the soldiers (by which I mean Puck, Muldoon, Robins, Karl), CJ (though she grew on me, I disliked her at first), Pegs and Riley. Pegs started out weak and got a lot stronger. Riley started out strong and got a lot weaker. Both of the voice actors for those characters did a good job. I also found myself liking Bricks, even though he was on the wrong side of the mess. Most of the rest were either uneventful, whiny or otherwise not all that interesting to me. And ye gods, Pippin's accent.
Now, to some plot points I especially liked and especially disliked:
First, for something I liked. Not so much a plot point, but I do appreciate how Lizzy and Bricks became fairly friendly. I thought that was a nice touch; humanized Bricks a bit and made it so the mallers weren't just faceless killers with no depth.
Next, something I intensely disliked, and it has to do with Lizzy. She is probably my least favourite character overall. She's useful as hell early on, then peters out, falls asleep at her post, gets booted, gets captured, then we spend most of season 2 wondering how they'll free her. Then Saul has to basically lie to CJ, who really just wants to be left alone, to get Lizzy back. And what does Lizzy do? She accuses Saul of not confessing everything to her involving CJ, then plays the hypocrite card and gets pissed when Saul calls her out about Bricks. Apparently it's okay for her not to specifically mention things, but not okay for him. Enormous double standard, and I think I'd have chucked her out a window to be dev--well, no, that's cruel, she was pregnant after all. But that seriously nailed her coffin shut. It was sad that she died the way that she did, but to my way of seeing it, Lizzy was dead weight after saving the tower, character-wise.
Next thing I liked: Kalani's arc. Yeah, I know the dude was a rat from the first, and made some really ugly choices. But it's got to suck to know that your daughter is in the hands of criminals, and it must've gutted him when the mallers shot her at the fake exchange. No wonder he went out in a blaze of glory. I think this was pretty well-played.
Okay, next thing I dislike: Ink, and more clearly, this whole obsession with staying put. The whole "we can't run" angle. When the big attack at the Colony happened, it was December. They only hit mass shortages in April. If they knew Ink was hanging around - and they did - and if they knew (as they should have) that fuel was going to run out, and water was going to be a problem, why the hell wouldn't they have made a point to scavenge fuel for the helicopter, and maybe even another helicopter or even a plane, to fly everyone out? It doesn't make sense that they'd stay holed up where they were, it feels too convenient. And then what burns me even more? Those missions to Radon Labs and to the jail. That jail thing just seems pointless. I mean seriously. You know you're dealing with a zombie, not something that can come chasing you. That argument of "we went a thousand miles to Boulder and he still followed" is bullshit, because there was panic involved and nobody tracked the biter that grabbed onto the chopper. As Tanya points out near the end, the only reason it's so bad in Los Angeles is that Ink and the humans are fighting for space and for survival. There would have been no shame in establishing a new base nearer to a much bigger supply of fresh water. They could have and should have done this. As such, a lot of the Ink-related stuff later just feels drawn out, and I find myself not caring as much what happened. I was just hoping to get to the end. Hell, even that long trek where Datu finally turned just felt like padding, though I confess the flashback where Michael lets Randy turn was a nice gut-punch.
Last thing I particularly liked: Burt losing his finger. God, that hurt to hear. Scott Marvin (Burt's voice actor) overdoes it a bit sometimes (as do many of them, really), but he did really well here. I have trouble watching that without flinching. Also, the scene in the helicopter where Lizzy dies...Saul's voice actor did an excellent job there. He was one of the more consistent voice actors in the series, IMO.
And one last thing I disliked fairly strongly. I get the sense that when Pegs and co. leave for Boulder, and she and Michael have a talk, we, the listeners, are supposed to root for Michael here, but I really, really don't. Michael knows that Pegs hates guns and will only use them if she absolutely must. When she says she wants to go to Boulder, says she doesn't want to become a soldier like Michael if it means losing her freedom, Michael says something like, "Well you have to stay here". Most of my respect for him vanished at this point, and it came back only slowly; I'm not the biggest Michael fan (except for "hit him again!", that was fucking awesome), but this was a low moment for him. I really hope there was a lot of good conversation off-screen between January and April, because if I were Pegs, I would have run far away and not looked back. People sorta shit on Pegs because she's sorta the quintessential peace-loving hippie type, but I think she was right here, and I'm not big on the slant I felt when listening to that episode. I'm with her; if given a choice to flee to someplace safe, or to become a soldier just so I can stay with my partner during an apocalypse, I'm pretty sure I'd flee. Staying alive trumps staying attached. Of course, as it turned out, it was all moot, but still.
Honourable mentions: Skittles for really overdoing the quick breaths meant to somehow indicate nervousness, Datu for having another unrealistic accent, Scratch for not knowing how to project her voice properly, Tardust for being a really slimy but believable villain, and Glen for literally sounding like he's reading his lines off cue-cards.
This was fun, but I don't think I'll be re-watching anytime soon.
Check out my Manamon text walkthrough at the following link:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/z8ls3rc3f4mkb … n.txt?dl=1