So, having completed the program at the Louisiana Center for the Blind, I suppose I have things to add, here.
First of all, I heard a surprising number of anecdotes about how people at other centers think LCB is too hard. TO this I can only say that, if all the others are less demanding, then I'm glad that I wound up at LCB. I also heard anecdotes of people's experiences at other centers, and based on all of this and my own experience, I'm pretty sure it's true. If you're an adult training program, give the student independent routes! Please! If you expect them to be in so much danger that you can't ever leave their side, then that's not helping!
Second, all the NFB trash-talking is simultaneously justified and totally wrong. Under what circumstances would you discover that someone is a member of the NFB? Probably when they tell you. Are the most reasonable members likely to bring it up without an appropriate context? Are they more likely than the ones who are the basis of the stereotypes? Na, probably not. Also I expect there is some (surprisingly small) exaggeration to the stereotypes, seeing as none of these hard core weird blind people rules evangelists ever show up where I can observe them for myself. On the other hand, there was a seminar at LCB that got uncomfortably close to implying that residual vision is a bad thing (nay, it was outright implied, even though they repeatedly disclaimed it explicitly), there are some pretty strong opinions (especially among the staff) about when it is and isn't OK to accept help, etc. Personally I'm staying out of it primarily because it seems contradictory to insist that it's not blindness which defines us, then go to monthly or biweekly meetings all about the fact that we're blind. And also the politics. That never ends well. (And I do mean politics, not advocacy.)
Also, since I started all this research, it seems a ton of so-called Structured Discovery Centers have been popping up all over the US, and it seems like many of them are modeled off the NFB centers, particularly LCB. I consider this a good thing, even if I disapprove of some of their methods and attitudes.
LCB's adult program has, as an end goal, actual independence. Even if they're the best at this in the country, I can't say that they're anywhere near perfect. People sometimes scrape through without actually gaining the skills (Kinda like me in high school and college), people sometimes graduate without being convinced in their ability to live independently, but probably the biggest failure mode is the "OK, so I have all these skills... now what?", which generally ends in someone being trapped in the same crappy home situation from before training. The program's purpose is to teach skills and confidence etc, not to clean up your life for you.
They do have some mechanisms in place to help, and staff students and former students are often more than happy to provide information or write letters or make phonecalls when they have the contacts. Only the "career counseling" is included as part of the package, and not very forcefully. They try to get students into "work study" if the situation permits, demands, or subtly gestures in that direction, write resumes, etc. (Notably the career counselors do not teach anything. I don't know if they'd talk you through writing a resume if you asked, or if that's the sort of thing the technology teachers are suppose to handle.)
I should probably note the pressure to get into high-status jobs, but that's pretty much all of western civilization. But that is a rant for another time.
So, I totally had an answer to "why would you need to demonstrate that you can prepare a meal for 40 people?" a week or two ago, and it has escaped me. So clearly it was not that impressive.
I think, though, that people in general have a hard time thinking in terms of meta skills. No, this is not a term or thing they talked about at LCB; it's more the "I don't want to do that and won't need to do that, therefore the fact that it teaches cross domain skills is invalid" attitude that often comes up. Though, yeah, there aren't a ton of options for how to do these things, which is a common complaint to which I have no objections. (The available options don't really bother me, but even hardcore NFB people coming through training have complained of it.)
So, I can get into specific complaints, like how seminar is usually "meh" at best and it replaces 4 hours of class time each week with 4 hours of sitting in one place, or how apartment instruction is... -_- maybe I will get into that later, but for now that would get away from the main point.
What did I like (besides the food)?
- the trip to the Horseshoe Ranch (in Jasper, Arkansas, if, you know, anyone has some free time and money to blow on wrestling an Ozark mountain). Zip-lining was way less awesome than I expected, horseback riding was worse than I expected and felt pretty pointless TBH, and everything else exceeded expectations. Although, admittedly, I think most people hated the rugged terrain. Given the lack of harassment from wildlife and the very distinct, very broad trails, I felt rather the opposite. The biggest downside is that after adapting to running up and down mountains multiple times a day, my body expressed its disappointment in returning to walking the streets of Ruston by taking it out on my mental state. Apparently, I function best when escalating. This probably explains my positivity toward LCB as a whole.
- The Whitewater Rafting trip in Ocoee, Tennessee was mostly underwhelming, especially the Whitewater Rafting. But that's probably just me. I didn't mind the side trip to Rock City, the ropes course was the best thing about the trip, paintball might have been more interesting if the staff of the facility didn't insist that we stand behind the farthest barricades and never leave, shooting soapballs, and I'd've enjoyed the pool more if the lifeguards hadn't concluded early on that I can't swim and insisted that I stay in an effing intertube (I kept my head in it long enough to swim to the exit, because forget that noise. Also they seemed eager to hand out tubes to everyone. If I want a wave pool, I'm going somewhere... ah, anywhere else, since the only thing that's come close was related to a school for the blind and made marginally more sense in context). Also, the mountain where we stayed in Ocoee was far less challenging than the Ozarks.
- I graduated before Mardi Gras. It does not sound like something I would enjoy.
- The extremely hands-off nature of everything. Sometimes this is taken a bit far (but I'll get to "Apartment Instruction" later), but it's overall a setting where you not only can fend for yourself, but are expected to, unless you demonstrate utter helplessness on arrival. Though, IMHO, people rely on cabs way more than they should. Sidewalks and even shoulders are scarce outside of the downtown area, but in spite of this Ruston is still small enough to walk almost everywhere. Almost. I would not want to walk to the hospital. Or wherever in the 9 Hells they sent me for my first drop route.
- BOOKS EVERYWHERE! BRAILLE WRITING MATERIALS EVERYWHERE! ... Oh crap I forgot to get my free roll of dynotape!
- Other than Braille and Tech and Seminar, the classes involve a lot of not-sitting. Sitting is the new smoking, you know.
- Some of the people are actually likable? I mean, the atmosphere feels less... I mean, WSB had lounges and rec trips, but I did not feel like I was in an environment that was worth the trouble, socially speaking. The 3 exceptions I can think of off the top of my head all got out of WSB at the same time I did. Like, the same day. Except for one, who was an LCB graduate who was there for the certifications. Meanwhile, LCB was not the least bit alienating, even though I still mostly kept to myself. It's hard to put a finger on the difference, but there was definitely a difference.
- I made it out without being evangelized to more than a tiny handful of times. And those were for Christianity, not the NFB. Although my second roommate did make a perfectly secure comment within 48 hours of arriving that he could not understand how anyone could make it through LCB without joining the NFB. ... Maaaaaybe I shouldn't show him this post.
Things I did not like:
- I do not mind Apartment "Instruction" in principal, but in practice, it's largely drillsergeant-style inspections with very little instruction (most of which amounts to "clean more" and "yeah, the cleaning supplies that the center provides aren't going to work and you should go buy stuff yourself"). So, let's see... the penalty for failing inspection is a $50 deduction from your maintenance check, but to pass inspection, you have to go buy cleaning supplies because the stuff they provide isn't up to the task? And it took over a month to get someone to actually show me the things I didn't know how to do! ... but when I got there they offered to teach how to operate the laundry machines. I'm not sure why they expect people to need laundry orientation but not housekeeping tutorials. Maybe they want to be certain they're not going to get people coming to training in week-old clothes, but figure the housekeeping is less urgent?
- You cannot get out of braille or tech. Now, in fairness, I expect the cutoff point for getting out of braille would involve reading at a minimum of 200wpm and doing something similarly fantastic with the slate and stylus, but still!
- Technology class. Undisputed least favorite. I'm sure you're thinking "But you won't stop going on tangents about fanciful technology, and you make games! Is it too easy, or something?" No. After I demonstrated I can type well over 80WPM on a good day and know Jaws well enough to pass the certification test, it was all Microsoft Office assignments of the most frustrating sort. Because I do not do well with essays, I am not an accountant and therefore do not care for Excel, and the rest of it was all about finding jobs and job interviews and such. The most interesting assignment I got was to contribute something to NVDA, because apparently making a couple audio games means I can do that. ... And it's wonderfully nonspecific about what to contribute.
- I felt like I was there for 9 months when I could easily have completed the requirements in 6, and it came down to scheduling and filler assignments. Now, I'm not saying they wanted to keep me there as long as possible for alterior reasons... but it was pretty frustrating from October to December.
- National Convention. I kinda wanted to go, because the idea of a big exhibit hall full of stuff I rarely get to see and a place where I can buy stuff I'd normally have to go through intermediaries to get sounded interesting, and I was not opposed to bumping in to random people I know from hereabouts. But those things were not worth it. YMMV.
So, most of the complaints I've heard levied at NFB centers are more of the "I hate my teacher / don't want to take this class" variety. So, basically, the complaints people make all throughout high school. Meanwhile, the complaints I heard about WSB involved rats, suicide, sexual harassment, and the police having to step in to prevent the director from forcing someone to leave the state and not just the program. Also, WSB apparently pulled the "drop everyone who will ruin your statistics" game.
Of course, LCB doesn't keep statistics, and they totally, totally should. No one has ever lost bodyparts in the woodshop, sure. What's the frequency of injuries requiring hospitalization or a hearse? What are the employment and earnings stats of LCB graduates compared to graduates from other programs and those who have not gone through such programs? I feel like there isn't really a good way to measure the outcomes I'm most interested in, and all of these suffer a huge form of selection bias in that the people who graduate LCB are usually people who wanted to go to LCB.
(Let me answer that injury question. While I was there, 3 major issues happened under sleepshades, two of which required hospitalization and surgery, while the other was so incredibly lucky I don't even. There was another which no one really can explain, in which an older student broke his hip, but I don't see this being dependent on the LCB experience. Then there was someone hospitalized for a bad seizure that involved a head-made hole in a wall, which also does not seem LCB-related. There was someone who may or may not have been injured before I got there and was using assistive equipment to get around (IDK how much... crutches? Scooter?) One of those serious injuries was freakishly specific. Assume everything else involved people getting hit by moving vehicles. There was also a (failed) suicide attempt, from which the person in question seems to have rebounded spectacularly.)
(The worst I got were some burns and scrapes, most of which are the sorts of things sighted people would get about as often, other than all those slanted sign posts and overhanging branches. I kinda feel like that's outweighed by the healthier eating and miles upon miles of walking alone... all of which have been notably absent since I got home. Must fix ASAP. >.<)
If there's anything more specific you're interested in that I did not mention, feel free to ask, and I will do my best to answer.
看過來!
"If you want utopia but reality gives you Lovecraft, you don't give up, you carve your utopia out of the corpses of dead gods."
MaxAngor wrote:
George... Don't do that.